ChatGPT's ability to do math

classic Classic list List threaded Threaded
4 messages Options
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

ChatGPT's ability to do math

OmegaKV
I am trying to come up with basic math problems ChatGPT cannot solve, and so far I have been unable to.

Here are the questions I asked it, all of which were written by me:

User
A cylinder has a radius of 5 inches and length of 3 inches. At one end of the cylinder, a half sphere with radius of 5 inches is attached at the face. What is the surface area of the combined shape?

ChatGPT
The surface area of the combined shape, consisting of a cylinder with a radius of 5 inches and length of 3 inches, and a half-sphere with a radius of 5 inches attached at one end, is approximately 251.33 square inches. ​​




User
One end of the cylinder is closed with the half sphere that was mentioned, and the other end is simply closed with a circular face.

ChatGPT
With the addition of a circular end to close the other side of the cylinder, the total surface area of the combined shape (a cylinder with one end closed by a half-sphere and the other by a circular face) is approximately 329.87 square inches. ​​


User
If the attached half sphere is removed and replaced with a simple circular face, then what does the surface area become?

ChatGPT
If the half-sphere is removed and replaced with a simple circular face, the total surface area of the cylinder with both ends closed becomes approximately 251.33 square inches. ​​




User
What is  50^0.75

ChatGPT
5
0
0.75
50
0.75
  is approximately 18.80. ​​




User
One line passes through (0,0) and (1,2), and another line passes through (1,1) and (3,4). Are these lines parallel?

ChatGPT
The slope of the line passing through the points (0,0) and (1,2) is 2.0, while the slope of the line passing through (1,1) and (3,4) is 1.5. Since their slopes are not equal, the lines are not parallel. ​​




User
A circle has an area of 10. For this circle, what angle would make an arc length of 5?

ChatGPT
For a circle with an area of 10, an arc length of 5 corresponds to an angle of approximately 160.57 degrees. ​​




User
A ball is dropped from a height of 6 feet. How long does it take for it to reach the floor?

ChatGPT
The ball dropped from a height of 6 feet will take approximately 0.61 seconds to reach the floor. ​​




User
A corner of a standard piece of paper is cut off with a pair of scissors and thrown away. The piece that was cut off was very small, less than 1% of the area of the original paper. How many sides does the paper have now?

ChatGPT
When a small corner is cut off from a standard piece of paper, the paper's shape changes. A standard piece of paper initially has four sides (a rectangle). Cutting off a corner creates two additional sides along the cut, replacing the one corner.

Therefore, after cutting off a small corner, the piece of paper now has five sides.




User
How many sides would it have if instead of cutting off a small corner, the paper was instead cut along the diagonal?

ChatGPT
If a standard rectangular piece of paper is cut along its diagonal, the paper is divided into two right triangles. Each triangle will have three sides. However, since the paper is split into two separate pieces, each piece (triangle) is considered independently.

Thus, after being cut along the diagonal, each piece of paper (now a triangle) has three sides.
It got all of them right. Only for the first one it didn't give the answer I was looking for right away, but there was some ambiguity in my question, and after being more clear it gave the answer I was looking for.

Is anyone here able to come up with a simple math problem that would be easy for a human to solve but which ChatGPT4 gets wrong?
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: ChatGPT's ability to do math

fschmidt
Administrator
me:
You have 3 glasses, 2 small and 1 big.  The small ones have water and the big one doesn't.  Then you pour the water from the small glasses into the big glass.  How many glasses of water do you have now?

ChatGPT:
After pouring the water from the two small glasses into the big glass, you will still have 3 glasses, but now the big glass will have water in it, and the two small glasses will be empty. So, you will have 3 glasses of water in total.
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: ChatGPT's ability to do math

OmegaKV
Did you use ChatGPT 3 or 4?

This is the answer it gave when I asked it the same question, using ChatGPT4:

You have 3 glasses, 2 small and 1 big.  The small ones have water and the big one doesn't.  Then you pour the water from the small glasses into the big glass.  How many glasses of water do you have now?

ChatGPT
After pouring the water from the two small glasses into the big one, you would have one big glass filled with water. The two smaller glasses would be empty. So, in total, you have one glass of water.
Reply | Threaded
Open this post in threaded view
|

Re: ChatGPT's ability to do math

OmegaKV
I found a problem it consistently gets wrong:

"A draw contains an unsorted collection of black, navy, white, and brown coloured socks. If socks are taken at random, one at a time, what is the minimum number which must be taken to be certain of finding five matching pairs?"

https://mathschallenge.net/view/unsorted_socks

It gives a different wrong answer every time. But it gives its reasoning which is almost correct, it just contains a few stupid non sequiturs in some of its steps, which result in a wrong answer.

A draw contains an unsorted collection of black, navy, white, and brown coloured socks. If socks are taken at random, one at a time, what is the minimum number which must be taken to be certain of finding five matching pairs?

ChatGPT
To determine the minimum number of socks required to ensure five matching pairs, we can use the "pigeonhole principle". This principle states that if n items are put into m containers, with n > m, then at least one container must contain more than one item.

In this scenario, there are four different colors of socks: black, navy, white, and brown. We want to find out the minimum number of socks needed to guarantee five matching pairs.

If we take four socks, one of each color, we don't have a pair yet.
To ensure at least one pair, we need to take one more sock (total of 5 socks), which will definitely match one of the previously taken socks.
To ensure a second pair, we can take up to 3 more socks (total of 8 socks), as the worst case is getting one more of each of the three remaining colors.
For the third pair, we need to take up to 3 more socks (total of 11 socks).
For the fourth pair, again, we may need 3 more socks (total of 14 socks).
Finally, for the fifth pair, we would need to take up to 3 more socks (total of 17 socks).
Therefore, the minimum number of socks that must be taken to be certain of having five matching pairs is 17. This ensures that even in the worst-case scenario, where we pick socks in a way that delays the formation of pairs as much as possible, we will still end up with at least five pairs.
I find it horrifying that it is this hard to find a problem it gives a wrong answer to. And I wouldn't call this problem "easy" for the average person to solve.